Classicism1883
Isle of the Dead
Arnold Böcklin
Curator's Eye
"The painting features a steep rocky islet rising from a glassy sea, in the center of which funeral niches are carved. A boat approaches, carrying a white coffin and a figure draped in white, standing, evoking a deceased person or a psychopomp guide. Dark cypresses, symbols of mourning and immortality, rise in the center, creating a funereal verticality that pierces the twilight sky."
An absolute icon of European Symbolism, Isle of the Dead is a meditative work on the passage to the afterlife. Arnold Böcklin captures a mineral and eternal silence, creating a dreamlike space that fascinated psychoanalysts, dictators, and composers alike. It is an invitation to contemplation, a picture built to "make one dream," in the painter's own words.
Analysis
A deep analysis of this work reveals a crucial transition in 19th-century art, from late Romanticism to introspective Symbolism. Painted in five versions between 1880 and 1886, the work was born from a commission by Marie Berna, a young widow who wanted an image for "dreaming." Böcklin moves away from classical narration to focus on atmosphere ("Stimmung"). The style is characterized by a quasi-photographic precision of rocky textures, contrasting with the unreality of the scene. The light seems to come from an invisible source, striking the white rocks to accentuate their spectral appearance.
Historically, the work fits into a period of fascination with Antiquity and Mediterranean myths, while prefiguring research into the unconscious. The mythological context is omnipresent here, though implicit. The boat inevitably evokes Charon crossing the Styx, although Böcklin never explicitly named the ferryman. The island itself is a synthesis of real sites (such as Ischia or the islet of Pontikonisi) transformed into a metaphysical architecture. This fusion between the real and the sacred creates a permanent psychological tension: the viewer feels both an intruder and a guest.
Böcklin's technique uses layers of tempera and oil to achieve a color saturation that gives the water the appearance of a black mirror. The psychology of the work is one of resignation and peace. Unlike medieval representations of death, there is neither dread nor judgment here. Death is a place of rest, a fortified enclosure against the tumult of the outside world. The rocky walls act as protective barriers, transforming the island into an inviolable sanctuary where time seems to have stopped.
Finally, the work's influence is unprecedented in art history. It inspired Rachmaninoff for his symphonic poem, as well as Surrealists like Dalí or Chirico. Isle of the Dead does not only represent the end of life, but the persistence of memory. It is the receptacle for the mental projections of the viewer, a window opened onto what Freud would later call the "Uncanny." It is a landscape of the soul as much as a geographical landscape.
One of the best-kept secrets lies in the third version (1883), commissioned by his art dealer. Böcklin added his own initials "A.B." on one of the tomb entrances in the rock wall, thus marking his own place in eternity. Recent X-ray analyses of the first version revealed that the painter had initially included a more terrestrial landscape before reconsidering to purify the image and reinforce the island's isolation.
A historical mystery links the work to Adolf Hitler, who owned the third version. He was fascinated by its Germanic and mystical character. However, the destiny of the fourth version is tragic: it was destroyed during the bombing of Berlin during World War II. Only black and white photographs remain, adding a dimension of "real death" to the history of this series of images about the afterlife.
A scientific anecdote highlights Böcklin's obsession with light. He used a shellac-based preparation to give a mineral glow to his whites. Chemical analyses showed that he sometimes mixed varnish with his fresh paint to create transparency effects in the water, mimicking the depth of the abyss. This concern for material detail contrasts with the purely spiritual subject of the canvas.
Finally, the island is not inspired by a single place, but is a mental collage. While many see the English Cemetery in Florence where his daughter Maria is buried, others recognize the rocks of Capri. The secret of its universal power lies precisely in this lack of precise location: it is the island of all the dead, a universal "non-place" whose spatial ambiguity reinforces its sacred and mysterious character.
Join Premium.
UnlockQuiz
What is the atmosphere evoked by this symbolist landscape?
Discover
