Romanticism1781

The Nightmare

Henry Fuseli

Curator's Eye

"A woman lies abandoned in sleep, while an incubus crouches on her chest. A spectral mare with bulging eyes emerges from velvet curtains to observe the night scene."

A manifesto of Dark Romanticism, this 1781 work explores the boundaries between dream and reality, desire and terror, through a Gothic iconography of unprecedented psychological power.

Analysis
First exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1782, Fuseli's "The Nightmare" marked a radical break with the then-dominant Neoclassicism. The work belongs to the context of "Sturm und Drang" and foreshadows Romanticism through its exploration of the irrational and the dark corners of the human soul. Fuseli does not paint a classical historical or mythological scene, but rather the subjective experience of nocturnal anguish. It is a work that captures the moment when reason falls asleep to give way to monsters, a theme that would later resonate in Goya's work. The explanation of the myth is based on Germanic and Scandinavian folklore regarding the incubus and the "Mara." The incubus is a male demon believed to lie upon sleepers to oppress them or have sexual intercourse with them. The term "nightmare" itself derives from "mare," an evil spirit that suffocates its victims. Fuseli gives body to these ancestral fears by materializing the demon in a simian and grotesque form. The myth here is no longer a distant fable, but a palpable physiological and psychic reality, transforming a superstition into a clinical study of sleep paralysis. Technically, Fuseli uses dramatic chiaroscuro to isolate the luminous female figure from the dark chaos surrounding her. The contrast between the ivory-white, almost ethereal body and the earthy tones of the demon creates an unbearable visual tension. The mare, although her name suggests a pun on "nightmare," was not present in the early sketches but reinforces the theatrical and spectral aspect with its chalky whiteness and vacant stare. The brushwork is fluid, almost hasty in the backgrounds, to accentuate the vaporous and unstable nature of the oneiric vision. Psychologically, the work is of abyssal complexity. It deals with sexual vulnerability and repressed desire. The woman's posture, with her head thrown back and arms dangling, suggests a state between ecstasy and agony, evoking a form of symbolic death. Fuseli projects his own personal obsessions, notably his unrequited passion for Anna Landolt, whose portrait was on the reverse of the original canvas. It is a pre-Freudian work that explores the libido as a dark and destructive force, making the viewer a complicit voyeur of this shadow theater. The mare and the incubus become projections of the tormented unconscious.
The Secret
One of the most fascinating secrets is linked to the artist's private life. Fuseli was madly in love with Anna Landolt, who had refused his marriage proposal. Analyses have shown that the woman depicted shares Anna's idealized features, transforming the painting into a kind of oneiric revenge or sentimental exorcism. It has also been discovered that Fuseli sometimes consumed raw meat or opium before sleeping to induce lucid and terrifying dreams, seeking to feed his inspiration through a direct experience of physiological horror. Scientifically, spectral analyses reveal significant pentimenti regarding the mare's head. This seems to have been added to satisfy a late iconographic necessity, creating that visual pun between the "mare" and the "nightmare." Furthermore, the painting had such an impact that during its exhibition, several women reportedly fainted at the violence of the suggestion. The work was widely disseminated through engraving, becoming the first "viral image" in art history, parodied by political cartoonists to criticize Napoleon or Pitt the Younger. Another mystery lies in the presence of the mirror or vial on the bedside table, often ignored. These objects refer to the pharmacopoeia of the time and to superstition: the vial could contain laudanum, suggesting the nightmare is narcotic in origin. The mirror, a symbol of truth, reflects nothing, emphasizing that we are in a purely mental space where the laws of optics no longer apply. It is this ambiguity between the medical and the supernatural that gives the work its lasting power and its status as a precursor to modern psychoanalysis.

Join Premium.

Unlock
Quiz

What creature is sitting on the chest of the sleeping woman?

Discover
Institution

Detroit Institute of Arts

Location

Detroit, United States