Symbolism1894
Melancholy
Edvard Munch
Curator's Eye
"Inspired by the heartbreak of his friend Jappe Nilssen, Munch abandons realism for a powerful symbolism where color and form dictate pure emotion."
A visual incarnation of introspection, Munch’s work captures the despair of a man contemplating a Norwegian shore, transforming the landscape into a mirror of a tormented soul.
Analysis
Painted in 1894, "Melancholy" marks a decisive step in Munch's transition toward Symbolism. The work is directly inspired by the unhappy affair between Jappe Nilssen and Christian Krohg, but it transcends personal anecdote to reach a universal dimension on human loneliness. The figure in the foreground, with his head resting on his hand in a classic iconographic pose of melancholy, seems unable to detach himself from his own interiority. This self-absorption is accentuated by the contrast between the dark, static mass of the man and the moving fluidity of the shoreline at Åsgårdstrand.
Munch uses the landscape as an extension of the psychic state. The curves of the coastline are not topographical reproductions but emotional waves that resonate with the subject's sadness. This concept, central to Synthetism and Symbolism, rejects objective observation in favor of the "memory of the image." The sky and water blend in twilight hues, creating an atmosphere of infinite waiting and regret. The silhouette in the distance on the pier, representing the happy couple or the departure of the beloved, acts as a visual catalyst for despair.
On a mythological and philosophical level, the work evokes the melancholic temperament, traditionally associated with the figure of Saturn. In the 19th century, this "black bile" was no longer just an illness but the distinctive sign of genius and modern sensitivity. Munch belongs to this lineage, where the artist is a suffering visionary capable of perceiving the underground currents of existence. The beach, a place of passage between solid ground and the unknown vastness of the sea, symbolizes here the fragile boundary between reason and madness.
The depth of the analysis also reveals an existential dimension linked to the philosophy of Kierkegaard, with whom Munch was familiar. The character does not only suffer from a lost love but from the anxiety of being. The landscape becomes a psychological prison where every element — the flat stone, the pier, the dark colors — contributes to a feeling of suffocation despite the openness of the space. It is this ability to paint "states of the soul" that makes Munch the precursor of Expressionism.
One of the most intriguing secrets of this 1894 version lies in its preparation technique. Munch used coarse burlap, a cheap material he favored because its grainy texture absorbed the paint unevenly. This creates a matte, earthy appearance that reinforces the feeling of heaviness and distress. It is said that Munch sometimes left his canvases outside in the rain or snow so that natural elements would participate in the erosion of the image, a process he called his "horse treatment."
An iconographic secret concerns the silhouette on the pier. Although often interpreted as Christian and Oda Krohg preparing to leave, Munch deliberately simplified these shapes to the point of abstraction. In reality, this scene echoes an earlier woodcut where the details were more explicit. In this painting, he erases the facial features to transform the characters into specters, reinforcing the idea that the protagonist in the foreground lives in a world of distorted memories rather than present reality.
The choice of pigments reveals a secret about the artist's mental state. Munch integrated Prussian blue and umber in a very diluted way, almost like watercolor in some places. This technique, unusual for oil at the time, allowed the "weave" of the canvas to show through. This visual void, these areas where the material seems missing, are direct metaphors for the internal emptiness felt by the melancholic subject, a technical innovation at the service of the emotional message.
Finally, X-ray analyses have revealed that under the current pictorial layer, Munch had initially sketched much more rigid forms. He radically simplified the composition during execution in favor of those large sinuous lines that became his signature. This transition from geometric structure to organic fluidity shows the artist's struggle to capture not what he sees, but what he feels, transforming a genre scene into a manifesto of modern anxiety.
Join Premium.
UnlockQuiz
What specific technical aspect of the 1894 version of "Melancholy" does Munch use to heighten the subject's sense of "internal emptiness"?
Discover
