Impressionism1880
The Asparagus
Édouard Manet
Curator's Eye
"The work focuses on a single asparagus stalk resting on the edge of a marble table, painted with a freedom of touch that verges on abstraction. Manet plays with a reduced palette of off-whites, delicate purples, and blues to magnify the organic texture of the vegetable against the cold minerality of the support."
An unprecedented pictorial audacity where a single vegetable becomes the unique subject of a masterful canvas. This portrait of an isolated asparagus bears witness to Manet's humor and his ability to transform the insignificant into a pure object of modern painting.
Analysis
Painted in 1880, this work is inseparable from another of Manet's paintings, "A Bunch of Asparagus." Charles Ephrussi, a famous collector and art critic, had bought the bunch for 800 francs. Manet, moved by the generosity of Ephrussi who had sent him 1000, decided to paint this isolated asparagus and offer it to him with a note that has remained famous: "One was missing from your bunch." This gesture illustrates Manet's spiritual courtesy and his rejection of academic conventions.
The asparagus here is not a simple element of traditional still life. Unlike 17th-century Flemish or Dutch compositions where vegetables served as a vanity or a display of imitative virtuosity, Manet treats the vegetable as a true individual. The object is extracted from any narrative context to become a pure study of light and matter. It is a radical affirmation: any subject, even the most trivial, is worthy of great painting if it is transfigured by the artist's gaze.
Technical analysis reveals a staggering speed of execution. Manet uses generous impasto to render the relief of the tip of the asparagus, mixing pigments directly on the canvas to capture the changing nuances of light. The choice of asparagus, a seasonal vegetable and a symbol of Parisian gastronomic refinement, anchors the work in the urban modernity of the late 19th century. It is a painting of the moment, of shared pleasure, and of wit.
Historically, this painting marks the final evolution of Manet's style toward an almost joyful luminous clarity, despite his declining illness. By simplifying the subject to the extreme, he anticipates 20th-century painting's research into the autonomy of the object. The asparagus becomes an excuse to explore the contrast between the warm white of the stalk and the cold white of the marble, a demonstration of craftsmanship that transforms a still life into a work of pure poetry.
Finally, the work highlights the intimate relationship between the painter and his collectors. It bears witness to an era when art was also an exchange of politeness and mutual recognition. By isolating this asparagus, Manet invites the viewer to silent and admiring contemplation, forcing us to see beauty where we did not expect it, an approach that defines the very essence of Impressionism and modernity.
The most famous secret lies in the price of the original work that spawned this one. Charles Ephrussi, having paid 200 francs more than the asking price for the bunch, unintentionally triggered the creation of this masterpiece. Manet did not simply want to "return" the money but to transform this monetary surplus into an artistic one. It is a unique case in art history where a financial overpayment becomes the catalyst for an iconic creation.
Another secret concerns the chromatic technique used for the whites. Manet almost never uses pure white. If you look closely, the asparagus is composed of bluish grays, straw yellows, touches of pink, and deep purples at the tip. This "Manet white" is a complex optical construction that gives the illusion of clarity while being saturated with colors. It is this alchemy that prevents the painting from appearing flat or inanimate.
The marble table on which the asparagus rests is not a trivial accessory either. X-ray analyses and provenance studies suggest that Manet used a corner of his own worktable in his studio on Rue d'Amsterdam. This mineral support, with its grayish veins, serves as an organic counterpoint to the stalk. The fact that the asparagus seems to "slip" toward the edge of the table suggests a temporal precariousness, as if the vegetable were about to disappear at any moment.
There is also an often-ignored symbolic dimension. At the time, asparagus was a luxury delicacy, often associated with eroticism in Belle Époque literature due to its phallic shape and rarity. By offering this isolated asparagus to a man, Manet was perhaps playing on a ribald and spiritual ambiguity typical of the Parisian spirit, transforming a still life into a coded sociocultural wink for high society initiates.
Finally, the conservation of the painting reveals a touching anecdote. Charles Ephrussi cherished this small canvas so much that he kept it on his desk rather than hanging it among his large old master paintings. The painting traveled through several prestigious collections before entering the Louvre, then Orsay, always remaining the ultimate example of the "fragmentary" painting that Manet was so fond of at the end of his life, favoring purity over decorum.
Join Premium.
UnlockQuiz
What specific historical circumstance led Manet to paint this isolated work and offer it to Charles Ephrussi?
Discover
